Alignment, contextualized.
"Before the game begins it is not only necessary to select a role, but it is also necessary to determine what stance the character will take - Law, Neutrality, or Chaos." (Book I) What stance will your character take? Law, Neutrality, or Chaos? What kind of question is that? Alignment. Its common uses: player prescription for character morality descriptor of a character's personality Trap mechanics (e.g. Nightwick Abbey) Language choice Its issues too limited of a moral descriptor too abstract/interpretable can be meta-gamed by objecting of what "REALLY" is lawful or something not actually descriptive of anything concrete My proposal Have a setting with clear opposing organizational sides, and only describe alignment in terms of the organizations In Times that Fry Men's Souls , describe the characters as British- or American-aligned or neutral In Nightwick Abbey, make it clear you're working to reclaim the abbey to its original purpose, simply loot...